"Academic Pressure: A Tragic Link Between College Assignments, Student Depression, and Psychoanalysis Study"

                                      

 

The tragic news headline "Mahasiswi Palangka Raya Bunuh Diri karena Depresi Tugas Kuliah" has become a hot topic of conversation in society. The reason is that the cause of this tragic incident, which is suicide in a student, was linked to her unstable psychological condition and the pressure from his coursework which she was unable to complete. This is in line with psychoanalysis theory which describes the psychological conflict that allows a person to carry out dangerous actions. Based on the theory of psychoanalysis by Sigmund Freud, psychoanalysis focuses on components that are divided into three, which are the id, ego, and superego, which can influence a person's thoughts, emotions, and behavior. These three balanced components can produce a healthy personality. Suicide due to both difficult assignment in college and large amounts of work can be understood as the result of a complex psychological tension between the instinctive drive to end suffering or excessive pressure (id), the difficulty in finding adaptive ways to cope with academic pressure (ego), and the internal moral pressure to achieve high standards (superego). Individuals use defense mechanisms such as denial or self-isolation as a way to cope with feelings of hopelessness and despair.

Kamenskaya (Agustina, 2013) wrote claiming that personality is actually a strong combination of traits and characteristics that set expectations, self-perceptions, values and behaviors and predict behavior. Characteristics that set expectations, self-perceptions, values and behaviors and predict individual reactions to other people, topics and incidents. Behavioral characteristics such as confidence, dominance, sociability, autonomy, self-defense, adaptability, and aggressiveness are common ways to describe a person's personality. Personality studies is a type of psychology that is based on the thoughts, research, or practical findings of case management experts. The object of personality studies is "human behavior", human behavior that is discussed about why, and how such behavior occurs. Environmental factors, heredity and circumstances can cause differences in a person's personality. These factors affect one's mindset, emotions, behaviour and system of socializing with the environment.

As an expert on personality, Freud generated ideas about personality. A theory proposed by Freud in 1923 that das Es, das Ich, and das Ueber Ich make up the framework of mental functioning. According to Freud, personality is a system made up of the id, ego, and superego. Each of these components plays a distinct part in an individual's personality. Id is said to be a natural characteristic of every individual and serves to preserve the consistency of that individual. Then, an individual's interactions with their surroundings, which point them in the direction of the reality that already exists, give rise to their ego.The superego, on the other hand, is a sociological concept that emerges from social processes in people who are influenced by others. Each of id, ego, and superego have the influence on the dynamics of a person's personality in producing an action.

            The id, ego, and superego can be used as a framework for seeing some events from the perspective of psychology. One of case that is the focus here is the suicide case of college students because of the college assignment. This case happened on Palangka Raya, 23 January 2023. A 19 year old college student was found suicide by hanging herself in her boarding house. Based on the news explanation she has a struggle related to the college assignment and tells her cousin about her problem. The victim often complains about her assignment and feels it is difficult to finish the assignment. The cousin also find her daydreaming in the moment before the victim found suicide.

In psychoanalysis, the id is the most primal and instinctual aspect of the personality. It is propelled by pressure and seeks to fulfill its needs and wants regardless of reality or morality. According to the report, “S” (the initial name student in the news) who committed suicide was depressed as a result of the many assignments she was unable to complete. This implies that the id was to engage in this scenario, as the student's desire for pleasure (in this case, the satisfaction of finishing her assignments) conflicted with reality (the fact that she could not complete the assignments). This conflict may have resulted in feelings of frustration, anger, and despair, ultimately contributing to the student's suicide.

The ego is “that part of the id which has been modified by the direct influence of the external world.” (Freud, 1923, p. 25) In particular, every living thing has an ego. A person's ego is a component of their personality that they are undoubtedly aware of and comprehend in themselves. When someone considers their own interests without considering the emotions or egos of others, they come to this realization. Additionally, they often attempt to project their own ego onto other people. The ego grows inside of us to act as a mediator between the false id and the outside reality. The part of the personality tasked with determining the prerequisites for decision-making is the ego.  The id is chaotic and irrational, while the ego functions best when it is grounded in reality but it can also be bad if it cannot suppress the ego properly and allows the ego to overpower itself and go beyond normal limits.In this case about “Mahasiswi di Palangka Raya Bunuh Diri karena Depresi Tugas Kuliah” there is a disturbance in the ego of the student, an ego that may not be able to find adaptive or effective ways to deal with stress with college  assignment  that cannot be completed or trauma experienced, so it is unable to protect itself from suicidal decisions.

            In this case supergo acts as a controller of the id and ego that exist due to the pressure experienced by the student. The superego plays a role in controlling the id here, namely by the emergence of thoughts not to end life because there are other reasons which may be different for each individual. Supergo here is also supposed to influence the id and ego to direct thoughts to more moral things. The supergo also might think about the effects of suicide. Those think maybe suicide is not good for the victim body or suicide might hurt. Something else like suicide will make the victim’s family sad, so it shouldn’t be done. In this case, suicide is also not good and not in accordance with religious norms. The construction of superego thinking in this case should be morally oriented and look at things from a sociological perspective. The superego is supposed to prevent or respond to logical sociological thinking but in this case it might be not as strong as the id and ego. The individual each thinking in this case might be different one and others. However, the superego here has a role to control and respond in logical, sociological and moral view to take an action.

The news entitled "Mahasiswi Palangka Raya Bunuh Diri karena Depresi Tugas Kuliah" highlights the possibility of a connection between students' mental problems and psychoanalytic theory. This news is based on the problems faced by the students who feel pressure from college assignments that she cannot complete, which causes the student to become depressed and decide to end her life. This is of course related to the theory of psychoanalysis by Freud which states that a person's id, ego, and superego influence the health of the mind. Based on this case, it can be seen that the student may be experiencing an imbalance in her own mental condition. So, in this situation, psychoanalysis can explain the internal conflict that led to the tragic incident that occurred to the student which was related to the imbalance of the id, ego, and superego.

In understanding the suicide of a student in Palangkaraya due to depression caused by college assignments, a psychoanalytic approach can help to see that the act may have been influenced by tensions between the id, ego and superego, namely, a dominant id in which the student experienced so much emotional or psychological pressure due to assignment that weighed on her mind that her id dominated and wanted release from this suffering by committing suicide. There is a disturbance in the ego, an ego that may not be able to find adaptive or effective ways to deal with the stress of college assignments that cannot be completed or the trauma it has experienced, so it is unable to protect itself from suicidal decisions. The critical superego creates a moral or internal conflict where the student feels unable to complete assignment  with her expectations or values, so she feels suicide is the only way out.

If we take a look from the perspective of the victim here and try to look from the personality theory, this case is influenced by id, ego, and superego when the ego maybe stronger than the other aspect. Based on the explanation from the news, the victim already tells about her struggle concerning her education matters, especially related to the assignment as a college student. Based on Freud theory there is a thing called ego mechanism when the individual has a  defense as a strategy that individuals use to prevent overt emergence from the impulses Id and superego. But here, it seems like this defense is not as strong as the id itself. It might be because the problem the victim faces is already stressing her out for a long time or she feels like there are no other ways to save herself from the situation. Whereas the id, ego, and superego need to be balanced because the imbalance will create a threatened feeling. In this case, the victim may feel this feeling because of her problem. And when id tends to dominate the mind, a person's personality will tend to do things impulsively, which can even harm other people because of indifference to order and norms. The victim might has this impulsive of action when she trying to end her suffering being did the suicide.

Based on this study, it can be concluded that the occurrence of suicides among "S" (the students in the news) who were depressed because of college assignments in Palangka Raya can be connected to the theory of psychoanalysis by Sigmund Freud seen from the perspective of the id, ego, and superego. The id, which is related to desire, may have been the reason that prompted the student's decision to end her life due to the pressure and despair that led to depression. Here, the ego shows that the student was unable to find another way to overcome the depression she felt which ultimately caused her to decide to commit suicide. Then, the superego focuses on social and moral norms that cause the id to overcome the ego and lead to a tragic event, namely suicide. In this case, this study emphasizes that balanced components of the id, ego, and superego are very important because they can influence a healthy person's personality who can control themselves not to take dangerous actions that could have tragic consequences.

 

The writers:

  1. Hesti Tustarina Handayani (2120302054)
  2. Amanda Lukmana (2120302058)
  3. Lia Adila (2120302061)

 

References

Syawal, H., & Helaluddin, H. (2018). Psikoanalisis Sigmund Freud Dan Implikasinya Dalam

Pendidikan. Banten. Uin Sultan Maulana Hasanuddin;2018.

Greatmind. (n.d.). Memahami Ego Dalam Diri [Understanding the Ego Within Yourself].

https://greatmind.id/article/memahami-ego-dalam-diri

Agustina, R. (2013). Tesis : Proses Berpikir Siswa dalam Penyelesaian Masalah Aplikasi

Turunan Fungsi Ditinjau dari Tipe Kepribadian Tipologi Hippocrates Galenus. Surakarta :Universitas Sebelas Maret.

https://www.simplypsychology.org/psyche.html

Rosa, M. C. (2024, Januari 24). Mahasiswi di Palangkaraya diduga bunuh diri karena stres tugas kuliah. Kompas. https://regional.kompas.com/read/2024/01/24/134625978/mahasiswi-di-palangkaraya-diduga-bunuh-diri-karena-stres-tugas-kuliah

 

 

Comments